If you are interested in a vacation property or second home, you may wonder about financing fractional home ownership. Before you move forward, it’s important to understand what fractional homeownership is and how financing works.
Fractional Home Ownership Financing Opportunities
Fractional ownership usually deals with owning a vacation property where several owners use it based on units of time. So, only one homeowner is allowed to use the property during a certain time. A fractional ownership policy can be used for a single-family home or apartment complex, and even a resort facility.
In a multi-family unit, each owner may own all the units, some, or only one. Also, usage rights and costs may or may not relate to rights of ownership.
A group using fractional home ownership can be set up by a real estate development business, building, seller, realtor, or various numbers of buyers and property users. Some also set this arrangement up with friends and family.
How Fractional House Ownership Is Different Than A Timeshare
A timeshare usually means several people share a property based on units of time, whether they own it or not. But there are several differences between timeshares and fractional ownership you should know.
It isn’t true that the difference between timeshares and fractional ownership is only whether the title to the property has been conveyed to the buyers.
Savvy consumers have been asking, “Is Fractional Home Ownership the Same as a Timeshare?” Let’s explore the differences and pros and cons of both opportunities.
Attorneys in real estate will tell you that some timeshares may have titled ownership and some fractional properties don’t.
The misconception above may lead to some misunderstandings:
- The assumption that restrictions and regulations on timeshares don’t apply to fractional ownership
- The buyers don’t evaluate the vital parts of a real estate deal to check if the fractional house ownership is better than a regular timeshare.
The major differences between the two arrangements are:
- How much each person’s rights and responsibilities are limited to a home or group of homes.
- How much each buyer owns and controls the property.
Having ownership to a home doesn’t mean that another owner can use the home. And having ownership also doesn’t give a co-owner any control over the way that the home will be maintained and managed.
At first glance, fractional house ownership and timeshares may seem like similar concepts. Both allow individuals to share ownership of a property, typically in a vacation destination, without the need to purchase the entire asset outright.
However, while they may share some common elements, fractional ownership and timeshares are distinct models of property investment.
Understanding the differences between the two can help potential buyers make an informed decision about which option best fits their lifestyle and financial goals.
So, is fractional ownership the same as a timeshare? No, they differ in several key ways, from the structure of ownership to the potential for financial return. Let’s dive deeper into the distinctions between these two forms of shared property ownership.
Ownership Structure
One of the most significant differences between fractional ownership and timeshares is the structure of ownership itself.
Timeshares typically grant you the right to use a property for a set period of time each year—often one or two weeks. However, you don’t actually own a part of the property. Instead, you are purchasing the right to occupy the property for a designated period. The primary appeal of timeshares is their affordability, as they provide regular access to a vacation property at a lower upfront cost. But, since you don’t have any equity in the property, you don’t have the benefits that come with true ownership.
Fractional ownership, on the other hand, is exactly what it sounds like—you are purchasing a fraction of the property. This means you are a partial owner and hold a deed to the property, which typically entitles you to a portion of the property’s value and the right to use it for a designated amount of time. Unlike timeshares, fractional ownership provides a tangible asset that can appreciate in value over time, allowing you to build equity. If the property’s value increases, your share of the equity increases as well, offering a potential return on investment.
Think of fractional ownership as owning a slice of a pie—you don’t own the whole pie, but your slice is yours to enjoy and profit from if the pie grows in value. In contrast, a timeshare is like renting the pie for a few weeks a year—you get to enjoy it, but you never truly own a piece of it.
Flexibility and Usage
Another key difference lies in how much time you get to spend at the property and how flexible that time is.
In a timeshare, you typically get one or two weeks per year, often during a specific period. If you wish to vacation at the same location every year during the same season, this setup can work well. However, the rigidity of timeshare schedules can be a drawback for those looking for more flexibility. While some timeshare programs offer the ability to swap time at one location for another, this isn’t always guaranteed and may come with additional fees.
Fractional ownership, by contrast, often provides more flexibility. Owners usually get more time at the property—ranging from a few weeks to several months per year—depending on the size of their ownership share. Additionally, many fractional ownership programs allow for more adaptable scheduling, giving owners the chance to choose when they want to use the property throughout the year.
Financial Considerations
One of the most important aspects to consider is the financial impact of each option.
Timeshares generally have lower upfront costs than fractional ownership because you are simply paying for the right to use the property, not to own a share of it. However, timeshare owners are still responsible for annual maintenance fees, which can increase over time. And, because you don’t own equity, there’s little to no potential for return on your investment when it comes time to sell.
Why invest in something that doesn’t allow you to build wealth or equity?
Fractional ownership may come with higher upfront costs, but it offers the potential for a return on investment. You own a share of the property, and as the property appreciates, so does your portion of the equity. In addition, because you have actual ownership, you can sell your share, often for a profit, depending on the market conditions.
While fractional ownership and timeshares both provide shared access to vacation properties, they are fundamentally different in terms of ownership structure, usage flexibility, and financial returns. Fractional ownership offers true ownership, equity building, and more usage time, making it a more attractive option for those looking for a long-term investment. Timeshares, on the other hand, are often more affordable but provide no real ownership or equity potential.
In the end, the choice between a timeshare and fractional ownership depends on your financial goals and how you plan to use the property. Understanding these differences ensures that you can make the best decision for your lifestyle and investment strategy
Why Consider Fractional Ownership of a Vacation Property?
Many people want a vacation home but cannot afford what they want. Or they won’t use the property enough to justify the cost.
Fractional ownership is a viable option to these issues by allowing the co-owners to pay part of the ownership and expense costs of owning the home.
They also can share the risks of unknown maintenance issues that can crop up.
However, as you spread the costs and risks, you will give up some rights to use the home as well as the freedom of having full ownership.
But having school and job responsibilities may prevent most of us from using our vacation homes for more than two or three weeks per year.
How To Finance Your Fractional Ownership Property
Now that you understand more about fractional ownership, let’s discuss how to finance that dream home.
There are four ways that you can finance this kind of home. First, you can buy your ownership stake outright, but most of us don’t have $100,000 or more in liquid funds to do that.
Next, you can tap the equity in your home with a second mortgage or equity line of credit. Doing this has many advantages. You can get a HELOC easier than a regular mortgage. You also can get a low interest rate with most second mortgages. Consider 2nd mortgage rate options and compare the home equity loans and HELOC.
Securing a mortgage for fractional property ownership can be difficult and is uncommon in the mortgage industry. Traditional mortgages are designed for equal ownership of a property, but fractional ownership brings added complexities that might deter many lenders.
Developer & Property Manager Financing Options
Many developers collaborate with banks to provide seamless financing solutions. Typically, a down payment ranging from 20% to 50% of the share price is required, with the loan being amortized over a short duration of 5 to 10 years. Below are some examples of traditional financing provided by fractional ownership firms as of October 2024:
- Pacaso: Offers financing for up to 70% of the share.
- Ember: Provides discounted financing on select properties.
- Vivla: Allows financing up to 100% of the share.
The other option is to obtain mortgage funding for your fractional home ownership acquisition. There are many mortgage companies that offer financing products for this situation.
You may be able to borrow up to 80% of the value of the home, so you may need to tap liquid funds or your home equity for the rest. In a few cases, the developer may offer to finance 10% of your share of ownership, you put down 10% and you get regular mortgage for the rest.
But remember that credit requirements could be stricter for fractional ownership than a regular home loan. Many mortgage companies want to see a 700-credit score and a debt to income ratio (DTI) of no more than 45%. Some lenders may have more flexibility for those with a 650-credit score.
Regarding documentation, it’s the same as a regular second home loan. So, you can expect to provide information on your assets, income, and liabilities. If you have all your paperwork in order, you may be able to close this loan in a few weeks.
The last option to finance a fractional ownership deal is to use financing that is offered by the developer. You usually need a 20% down payment for this kind of financing, and the loan may be amortized over five years, but a balloon payment at the end can probably be financed. Learn more about investment property loans.
Takeaways on Financing Fractional Home Ownership
Many people want to own a vacation home but have trouble affording it or justifying the expense. When you finance a fractional home ownership arrangement, you may be able to afford what you never dreamed of.
It’s crucial to differentiate between co-ownership and fractional ownership. In a typical co-ownership scenario, such as when two individuals buy a house together, they usually split ownership equally. However, in fractional ownership, one of the owners might hold a larger or smaller portion of the property than the other(s), which differs significantly from the equal share structure of traditional co-ownership.
About RefiGuide
Bryan Dornan is a financial journalist and currently serves as Chief Editor of RefiGuide.org. Bryan has founded several mortgage and marketing companies and has worked as a loan officer and mortgage broker in the industry for over 25 years and has a wealth of experience in providing mortgage clients with the highest level of service in the industry. Bryan's continual focus is to promote affordable home-ownership to consumers like you across the United States. He also writes for RealtyTimes, Patch, Buzzfeed, Medium and other national publications. Find him on Twitter, Muckrack, and Linkedin
More articles by RefiGuide